Episode 99: Best Mysteries Podcast 2025 in Review

It’s our 2025 year in review. Check out the best mysteries and thrillers from 1939-1943! Listen in — and stay mysterious.

Episode 95: Good Mystery Podcast 2026 Reading List

Introducing our 2026 reading list! The best mysteries from 1943-1948! Check it out!

Episode 83: 2024 Retrospective (Mysteries, Thrillers & Detective Fiction)

Carolyn Daughters and Sarah Harrison discuss the history of mystery (1934-1939)!

Episode 74: Rebecca Book (Daphne du Maurier)

Special guest Shana Kelly joins us to discuss Daphne du Maurier’s thrilling 1938 masterpiece.

Episode 73: 2025 Mystery Fiction Books

Get the scoop on all the amazing thrillers and mystery fiction books we’ll read in 2025!

Episode 72: Rebecca and Manderley

Special guest Shana Kelly joins us to discuss Daphne du Maurier’s thrilling 1938 masterpiece.

Carter Wilson – The Father She Went to Find

Carter Wilson is the USA Today bestselling author of nine standalone psychological thrillers. He’s an ITV Thriller Award finalist and five-time Colorado Book Award winner. We met with him and his cat, MacGuffin, at his home in Colorado to discuss his latest book, The Father She Went to Find.

Malice Aforethought: Best Crime Novels

Sarah, Carolyn, and guest Nate Harrison find Dr. Edmund Bickleigh entertaining, confusing, and terrifying. He has an inferiority complex with a big, whopping side of superiority. I guess everyone has truths that they hide from the world. What are we each hiding? And why?

Malice Aforethought by Francis Iles

Nate Harrison joins Sarah and Carolyn to discuss superman complexes, people who murder their spouses, and reasons why no one should ever eat a potted meat sandwich. Malice Aforethought ranks #16 in the Top 100 Crime Novels of All Time (Crime Writers’ Association). It’s worth a go!

Father Brown Stories

Our fabulous guest Deb Donner is back to discuss the stories in The Innocence of Father Brown. (By now, you surely have a copy of the book, right?) Father Brown solves mysteries by looking into men’s and women’s hearts and souls. We’re talking human nature, folks. It’s some heady, thought-provoking stuff.